Old Money Luxury

The Socialite Who Threw the Party That Ended an Era and Was Never Seen in Society Again

She threw a $1 million party. She sued the IRS and won. Then she disappeared.

Old Money Luxury's avatar
Old Money Luxury
Nov 15, 2026
∙ Paid

On August 5, 1989, an actress posed nude as Rembrandt’s Danaë under a tent on a Long Island tennis court, as the financier James Wolfensohn reportedly asked her to dance.

Twins dressed as mermaids swam in the pool. On the tables, heavy brocade cloths fringed with gold held treasure chests overflowing with pearls.

Every guest on that lawn was looking at money, and all of it came from one man’s appetite for other people’s companies.

He was Saul Steinberg, and the party marked his 50th birthday, thrown by his wife, Gayfryd Steinberg.

Gayfryd watched from the edge of the tennis court as her guests took in every spectacle she commissioned, all of it a tribute to a husband whose whole career ran on wanting what others owned.

At 29, Saul bought Reliance, an insurer ten times the size of his own firm. Years later, Walt Disney paid him roughly $58 million to sell back his shares and leave the company alone.

Gayfryd spent a full year of her own Reliance dividends on the pearls, the brocade and the mermaids, a sum reported at roughly $1 million.

Yet every dollar of it rested on Saul’s deals, and money that arrived that fast could vanish just as quickly.

And Gayfryd learned the second half of that lesson first.

This wasn’t the first time Gayfryd’s life rested on a husband’s fortune, and the last time, she ended up taking on the United States government to keep it.

The Chandeliers

Gayfryd Steinberg

Before she took on the United States government, Gayfryd’s world was a modest, thoroughly middle-class home in Nanaimo, British Columbia.

Gayfryd McNabb was born there in 1950, the daughter of Ross McNabb, a telephone company clerk, and his wife, Margaret.

Vanity Fair’s celebrated 1986 profile called them “humble Canadian beginnings,” and the magazine savored the contrast with where she ended up.

At 19, Gayfryd left the University of British Columbia and married a metallurgical engineer. She moved with him to South Africa, half a world away from Vancouver, and finished college there.

The country was in the grip of apartheid, a rigid social order in which a young Canadian engineer’s wife held a narrow place. For a clerk’s daughter, it was an early lesson in how much a wife’s standing rested on her husband.

By 1973, the couple had moved on to New Orleans.

Yet a new city couldn’t hold them together, and Gayfryd, who left university at 19 for a wedding ring, moved fast whenever her life changed course.

In 1976, the marriage ended, leaving Gayfryd in her mid-20s and on her own, far from home.

Within a month, she married Norman L. Johnson, a local businessman 21 years her senior who owned a company selling oil pipes. His money bought one of the grandest addresses in the city, a mansion at 6145 St. Charles Avenue hung with chandeliers worth up to $75,000 apiece.

St. Charles Avenue, New Orleans, is home to lavish mansions (Credit: NewOrleans.com)

In 1983, federal agents pulled the chandeliers from Norman Johnson’s ceiling.

Gayfryd settled into the life of a wealthy Louisiana wife one room at a time. Sumptuous antiques filled the Italian Renaissance villa, and Impressionist paintings went up on its walls.

With the rooms furnished, she opened its doors for elaborate charity dinners, trying to make a name in New Orleans separate from her husband’s.

Yet the city’s old money establishment refused to accept the couple, and the federal government took a closer interest.

The IRS charged Johnson with evading taxes on $7 million, and its agents came for the house along with the man.

They disconnected the wiring to get the fixtures down. Courts later fought over whether the chandeliers counted as furnishings or as part of the building, and liens went onto everything Johnson owned.

Then, in June 1983, the IRS turned on Gayfryd.

The government handed Gayfryd a personal tax demand for $4.8 million, roughly $15 million today, and it wanted the money at once.

Suddenly, everything of value in Gayfryd’s own name sat within the IRS’s reach.

Her paintings went into storage at the New Orleans Museum of Art, and her jewelry went into a vault at the Hibernia National Bank.

Gayfryd took the IRS to federal court and won.

She challenged the IRS’s attempt to seize her property in federal court, and the government, represented by the office of U.S. Attorney Rudolph Giuliani, capitulated before the hearing.

When prosecutors failed to fully comply with the court’s order, the judge made the United States pay her legal costs, a rare outcome in a case against the government.

She faced no criminal charges.

Johnson, on the other hand, pleaded guilty and received a 14-month prison sentence in May 1983. Gayfryd had already filed for divorce, which would be finalized that December. Two years later, in 1985, Johnson took his own life, a grim coda to the chandelier years.

Her own story, meanwhile, was heading north to Manhattan.

She was 33 and divorced for the second time. Of all the hostesses she would soon dine beside in New York, Gayfryd alone knew how it felt to sue the United States government and make it pay her lawyers.

Yet months before the IRS sent her the bill, a supposedly chance encounter at a New York society dinner party seated her beside a far richer man, whose fortune would crown her and then disappear.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Old Money Luxury.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Old Money Luxury · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.